Handyman shook up The Masked Singer premiere, with the panelist guessing him to be Vin Diesel, Idris Elba and Tone Loc.

The panel of sleuths are all over the place when it comes to Snow Cone's identity, but Gold Derby is convinced: it's Mischa Barton! The 39-year-old actress rose to fame on Fox's The O.C., and many of the clues directly relate to that primetime soap opera.

Contestants must wear special sweatshirts that say "Don't Talk to Me" on them, so people on The Masked Singer team know who to avoid. Pestis made clear that the shirts didn't come about "because of publicity," but rather to prevent confusion between staff and the stars.